How Authoritarianism creeped under Modi Regime


We are witnessing an illiberal authoritarian regime under the Modi government since he came into power in 2014. Although the stage was set up by RSS and BJP stooge Anna Hazare in 2011. He was sent to Delhi to discredit the Congress-led UPA government and malign its image by cooking up fabricated corruption charges and organising the “India Against Corruption” movement to misguide and cheat the Indian masses. The nation’s mainstream media also went against the Congress government to discredit it. The mainstream print and television media behaved as if they were vouching for regime change at any cost.
Narendra Modi observed the situation from 2011 to 2014 carefully. After winning the 2014 general election with a thumping majority, he implemented the rulebook of an illiberal and authoritarian regime. He saw the nature and style of functioning of civil society, the media, bureaucracy and judiciary as Chief Minister and Prime Ministerial candidate. Then he applied the standard authoritarian rulebook under his rule to govern the country.
He started by demonising and vilifying the opposition, especially Congress, and gave the slogan “Congress Mukt Bharat”. He labelled the whole opposition as anti-national and the real culprit behind people's suffering. Modi used the defence forces as an example to prove his point. Whenever he had to label Congress as anti-national, he pointed out that Congress had weakened the armed forces and restricted the Indian Army from attacking Pakistan whenever terrorist attacks happened on Indian soil. The mainstream media played along with his rhetoric to discredit and demonise the Congress party. In the authoritarian playbook, the first step is to villainise and demonise the opposition, and Modi did so strategically on this front.
After vilifying the opposition, he turned his tide towards the judiciary. Modi appointed ideologically aligned judges in the judicial system and manipulated judgements that benefited his governance in the long term. The judiciary helped the Modi government in the Rafale deal scam, Ayodhya verdict, voter list manipulation, et al. With the help of a committed judiciary, Modi governed without any obstacles at the top because the sole responsibility of the Indian judiciary is to protect the Constitution, but the Indian judiciary let down the country and gave a free hand to Modi’s populist authoritarianism. For example, before the West Bengal Assembly election, the Election Commission of India conducted an SIR (Special Intensive Revision) and deleted approximately 90 lakh votes, the majority of which belonged to eligible voters. However, when a special tribunal was established to hear the grievances, the judge orally said that “if you can’t vote this time, the world won’t end; you can vote next time”. So, the judiciary is openly helping the BJP and Modi in voter list manipulation. The same method was applied to appoint and promote committed bureaucrats for policy implementation and running the government. Since Modi took office as PM, he has brought his own people, committed to him ideologically and politically, to the helm of affairs. One such example is that he gave an extension to the Enforcement Directorate chief for the sixth time, and ultimately, the Supreme Court of India had to intervene to stop the chief’s extension. The Modi government brought parliamentary legislation to give legal protection to Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. Under the law, no legal action would be taken for his actions. This is a rare case in Indian history where a bureaucrat has been provided with such blanket protection for his actions. After CEC Gyanesh Kumar got legal protection, he started SIR in every upcoming Indian state, and under SIR, random deletions of voters from the electoral rolls came into action. With the help of the Election Commission, Modi and the BJP targeted certain groups, castes and religions that usually do not vote for the BJP. In the quintessential authoritarian system, committed bureaucracy and judiciary are the most important tools to manage the regime, and Modi has mastered them.
In the classic authoritarian rulebook, the control of the media and browbeating independent media are the next courses of action. After coming to power in 2014, Modi strategically controlled and manipulated Indian media. The mainstream media became pro-Modi, pro-BJP and anti-opposition. Modi and his policies became the focal point of all coverage, and the media became sycophantic towards the BJP and Modi. Instead of asking questions about the ruling BJP government and Modi’s policies, Indian mainstream media repeatedly asked questions of opposition parties and Congress about its history. On the other hand, the Modi government helped its crony capitalist business houses take control of the remaining independent media houses. For example, Adani took over NDTV after the Modi government fabricated tax and regulatory charges against the owner of NDTV. There are many such instances where the Modi government put journalists in jail, while its cronies filed defamation cases against social media platforms, YouTube-based independent and honest journalists, and organisations. The Modi government took a firm grip on public broadcasting channels DD News and Rajya Sabha TV and used them as its own propaganda tools to propagate its agenda.
After taking firm control of mainstream media, the Modi government imposed stricter control over the internet whenever it thought that information could have an adverse effect on its image. It shut down the internet in Kashmir and Manipur for months because it didn’t want ground realities and adverse information to reach the masses, which would damage its populist and strong-leader image. During the CJP (Cockroach Janta Party) protest at Jantar Mantar, the government shut down the internet to block the flow of information. Control of social media posts, mainstream media, print media and the internet are tools to establish an authoritarian regime and propagate a tyrannical agenda.
Universities, civil societies and NGOs are vital to free and independent societies. The RSS hierarchy and Modi knew this. They tried to curtail the funding of NGOs working in India on the grounds of foreign funding and choked the voices of universities like JNU. The whole BJP machinery termed JNU students as anti-national elements and appointed their own ideologues as professors and vice-chancellors in Indian universities. The Modi government captured the Indian education system and tried to change it to make it suitable for his rule and ideology on a long-term basis. Capturing the education system is another rule in the authoritarian playbook.
Control of national finances is another area where the Modi government established its stronghold. They intimidated business houses that had earlier supported opposition parties and, with the help of ED, CBI and Income Tax authorities, fabricated tax and fraud charges to victimise the owners and enabled their cronies to take over existing businesses. On the other hand, they helped their crony capitalist friends by providing them with government contracts and control over major financial structures of the nation. The way Modi helped Gautam Adani and Mukesh Ambani was beyond the normal regulatory framework and perfected the monopolistic market to control India's economy and markets. These crony capitalists, in return, helped Modi and the BJP through political funding for elections. One such example is demonetisation. Modi abruptly announced demonetisation, rendering every ₹500 and ₹1,000 currency note useless, and this step hugely benefited a few corporate houses with a pre-existing plan to launch online money transfer apps. Modi allotted Hasdev forest in Chhattisgarh to Adani at a minimal price, and despite all the protests and opposition from local tribals, he didn’t budge from cancelling that allotment. Under the Modi regime, the blend of crony capitalism and monopoly has destroyed the Indian economy. Crony capitalism and monopoly have killed small and medium businesses, which were the backbone of the Indian rural and semi-urban economy. Demonetisation and the wrongly implemented GST were the last nails in the coffin of the Indian economy. Gautam Adani was also implicated in the USA on corruption charges, but Modi signed the Indo-US trade deal to protect Adani from the American Justice Department and courts. The Adani and Ambani duo are controlling the whole of the Indian economy and profiteering at the cost of common Indian citizens, with Modi helping them at every step for his political benefit.
In the 2024 general election, Modi couldn’t muster a majority on his own, and now he has to run his government with the help of two allies. He has never had such an experience as an administrator, so now, keeping the 2029 general election in mind, he wants to implement delimitation across India to change the number of constituencies from 550 to 850. He wants to increase the seats in such a manner that only North Indian states would be enough to secure a full majority in the Lok Sabha. He also wants to carry out gerrymandering to manage individual constituencies where he can create a winning combination by excluding minorities, Dalits and those who do not vote for the BJP. In authoritarianism, gerrymandering of constituencies is another tool to manage elections and make the opposition toothless. In the state of Assam, the state BJP government carried out delimitation and managed the constituencies according to its own political benefit. They gerrymandered the constituencies illogically and unconstitutionally, without any continuity. They did this to manage Muslim voters, who usually don’t vote for them.
These above-mentioned practices are archetypical authoritarian styles of governing a nation. We have seen leaders like Viktor Orbán in Hungary, Jair Bolsonaro in Brazil, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan in Türkiye and Donald Trump in the USA; these are all populist authoritarian rulers who want to capture the nation and subdue democracy. They all follow the quintessential rulebook of illiberal authoritarianism. There is historical evidence that such autocrats follow and get inspired by other autocrats from different parts of the world. They borrow tactics and rhetoric from one another; they inspire other populist leaders. Initially, Modi and Trump behaved like buddies, but they fell out after Modi didn’t follow Trump’s line of command. However, initially, they inspired each other.
So, the most important question is: From whom did Modi take inspiration for his authoritarian form of government in India, where democracy and the Constitution are the soul of this country? Our freedom fighters and nation-builders only dreamed of making India a republic and establishing democracy for the people, by the people and of the people.
Modi’s idea of governance matured during his time as Chief Minister of Gujarat. He got a free hand as Chief Minister without any credibly strong opposition, and the Congress party did take him lightly and never pushed him to check his democratic limits. Modi tasted the blood of authoritarian-style governance, and he did get a full majority in his first term as PM from 2014–19. During his first tenure, the opposition was utterly weak, and he rode on his popularity with the support of the masses. But after two and a half years, when he carried out demonetisation, he realised that he had self-sabotaged the Indian economy, and to remain in power, he either had to deliver on his promises or control and capture the system to retain power. His popularity was dwindling before the 2019 general election, but the Pulwama terrorist attack happened, and he carried out air strikes in Pakistan. Then a new wave of nationalism arose among the Indian public, and he garnered much better support and more seats in the election. After that, there was no coming back. With a falling economy, high inflation and joblessness, he couldn’t bring the Indian economy back on track but gave his supporters a dose of religion, creating an aura of an infallible PM unlike any India had ever seen. He gradually implemented the authoritarian style of governance through control, intimidation and populist rhetoric.
History has shown us that a dictatorial regime has its life. It became a form of government impetuously and it fell impulsively.

