Hallucination of Indian Communists

Ganpat Ram, Robert Yadav

10/26/20265 min read

Indian communists’ ideology was wholly borrowed, firstly from Moscow and then from Beijing. They had core convictions based on borrowed ideology, and they tried to implement it in Indian society without any reinterpretation according to the Indian society and values in which they wanted to execute it. Their stubborn ideological stand vis-à-vis political, economic, social, and cultural transitions in India made them irrelevant, and now they are fighting for their existence more than ever. They couldn’t interpret their ideology and make any formative changes according to their convictions that would be more suited to present Indian political, social, and economic issues.

Indian communists played a suspicious part in the Indian independence struggle; then they tried to disapprove of Indian independence, which we got on 15 August 1947. They never accepted the Indian Constitution and our country as a republic. Whilst remaining ignorant, they fought elections, won a few after brief electoral defeats, but violence was always their first resort to change the system under the pretext of revolution. Revolution was always their stock phrase, and they are still carrying that filler as their political expression without understanding the psyche of the Indian masses. They never tried to understand the psychological indentation of the Indian people. We all know that non-violence is an inherent value of Indian-ness, but they always want to bring violence through the pretext of revolution. Indian communists never understood the concept of nationhood and patriotism. They have a problem with nationalism, but they don’t know when and why nationalism must be applied for a nation. They always use an archaic word, “nation-state”, which was borrowed from Greece. So, they don’t want to modernise their doctrine and ideology with concepts that suit the existing time and space.

Indian communists talk about labour laws and labourers’ rights but never try to maximise the production and industrialisation of the existing industrial setup. For example, they ruled West Bengal for 34 years, but they never tried to modernise the existing jute industry in Bengal; eventually, the jute industry in Bengal was completely destroyed by them. They ruled Tripura for 25 years consecutively, but they kept Tripura as they got it. They will talk about a modern economic education system, but they never tried to implement that in Tripura and West Bengal. They will talk about Jawaharlal Nehru University, but they never emulate it in their ruled states.

When Indian Prime Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh wanted to sign the Indo-US Nuclear Trade Deal, they vehemently opposed the trade deal and withdrew their support from the government in which they were alliance partners. The Indo-US Nuclear Deal was a turning point in the Indian geopolitical spectrum; they couldn’t envision the need of the hour. That withdrawal of support was the last nail in their political coffin. In the next general election of 2009, they were nowhere in the picture of Indian politics, and subsequently, they lost all their ruling states in successive elections. Still, they didn’t learn their lesson. Under the fascist rule of PM Modi, they couldn’t devise any transformative approach in their doctrine and keep using the same pet phrase of revolution and change without any innovative and profound politics. Now, they are behaving more like parasites that get stuck to something for sustenance. They will definitely create news on social media and in the mainstream media, but they won’t provide a roadmap for what they are doing and what they envisage doing.

During the CJP (Cockroach Janta Party) movement at Jantar Mantar, the Left party’s student wing formed a latent alliance with CJP activists, and in return, CJP wanted their support for people’s mobilisation. As we all know, CJP members were wholly supported by AAP (Aam Aadmi Party), and they worked for AAP in the past. And AAP is a product of the Anna Hazare movement of 2011, which was devised and funded by RSS. So, indirectly, Indian communists are totally trapped by RSS and BJP at present in Indian politics, so why should a common Indian citizen vote for Left parties if they are indirectly helping RSS and BJP? Left parties and their student wing must answer questions about their collaborative structure to the common people.

During the Anna movement, Indian communists did the same thing; they wholeheartedly supported Anna Hazare’s India Against Corruption movement, which had no legal basis, as was proved in court. So, basically, after liberalisation, when India went through a phase of economic growth, Indian communists lost their political footing because they couldn’t comprehend the people’s psyche and demands. Communist ideology itself isn’t conceptualised for modernised science and technology and a globalised economy. Russia and China changed their approach according to the demands of time and space; China is becoming an ultra-capitalist and modern economy based on advancements in science and technology, but Indian communists are still living in the era of the Russian Revolution. Indian communists lost the ideological plot and doctrine; their ideology is obsolete and anachronistic. If they want to command the appeal of Indian voters and the minds of people, they need to reinvent themselves and bring a remodelled package of politics. They will talk about the Constitution, republic, democracy, constitutional rights, and social justice, but their communist ideology itself isn’t conceptualised for the Constitution and democracy. How could you talk about the Constitution and a democratic nation when you talk about revolution? Both can’t go on concurrently. They must clarify what they really want and what they would do if they get political power.

On the social spectrum, they never gave prominent representation to Dalits, tribals, and backward classes in their main political hierarchy. Post-Mandal politics, they gradually lost their appeal among voters when the Indian political milieu went through caste mobilisation. They didn't change themselves, but voters changed their voting patterns. When political parties mobilised their voters on caste and religion, the Indian Left didn't co-opt caste and religion, which is the bitter truth of Indian society. Asking voters to vote on proletarian and bourgeoisie issues never gained a foothold in India except in a few pockets.

They will always talk about women’s empowerment and representation, but they won’t answer why not a single woman has been given a chance to rule any state of theirs or been appointed as the most powerful general secretary. If we read their history, they never practised what they preached. And they have always directly or indirectly helped and aided fascist forces like RSS and BJP.

They will only ask questions of the Congress party, like BJP does, but they would come to the Congress party and cling to it like scroungers for their survival. And the Congress party, since its formation, has always had an umbrella organisation that accommodates everyone who aspires to nation-building, but nowadays, communist and fascist ideologues who cling to Congress are just there for political survival and to make money. Congress needs to be more careful than ever before of these elements.

If Indian communists want to be real game-changers in Indian politics, they must start from scratch. They must stop behaving like scroungers and build their own political base, not only in academia but more at the basic ground level of the political sphere. And they must clarify their ideology, which should be acceptable to Indian psychology and values. They must know that Indian-ness lies in non-violent philosophy; they must stop invoking revolution at every stage. They get inspired by Bhagat Singh, but Bhagat Singh was a non-violent man at heart. He threw a bomb in the Legislative Assembly as a symbolic expression to be heard by the British authorities, not to blow the bugle for violence at large. Last but not least, stop behaving like leeches; be a political force to reckon with.

Contacts
nehrustudycirclejnu@gmail.com
Copyright © 2026 nehustudycircle.com
The NSC is not responsible for the content of external sites